Welcome to Witches Brew Coffee House
Witches Brew Coffee House located in West Hempstead, NY is a beloved haunt for locals and visitors alike. This women-owned cafe offers an extensive menu of Italian and American cuisine with a focus on vegan and vegetarian options. The ambiance is described as cozy and spooky, reminiscent of a 90s Halloween special. Customers rave about the food, from the well-dressed Caesar salad to the delectably buttery Inkwell latte. The wait times can be long, but the exceptional service, delicious food, and unique decor make it worth the wait. With a cash-only policy, this cafe is a perfect spot for a date or study group, offering a truly memorable dining experience.
Witches Brew Coffee House: Reviews & Ratings
Ambiance was 10/10. Dessert was good but I was underwhelmed by the s'more I got. Service was excellent and quick.
Food and service is always amazing. Really a staple of Long Island eateries . The atmosphere is always relaxed and comfortable. A diamond in the rough.
Rate 4 stars. Food was amazing and staff was nice. Very attentive. My only issue is the system with the wait times. We waited outside for almost an hour. And that was inconvinet but it was worth the wait
Definitely join the wait list if you are looking to come here because the wait can be hours!!!! That being said, this place has such a long wait because it is so amazing. The food is UNREAL, the vibe is adorable and antiquey inside, they have a vast amount of vegan, vegetarian, and gluten free options, & the coffee is some of the best you'll get. There's a reason why the wait is so long, and it's because it really is amazing. One other thing to note is this is a cash only facility, but they do have an ATM at the front. Perfect place for a date or study group!!
I can see why this place has become a landmark for Long Island.
Inside is cozy and spooky. Like walking into a 90s halloween special. The menu is quite extensive. Pretty much everything is vegetarian/vegan, but still delicious regardless. I had a Ceasar salad which was well dressed and kept me full. And an Inkwell latte which was delightfully buttery and sweet like a Butterbeer.
I showed up right as it opened at 12pm and was seated immediately, served, and out in about 30ish minutes (I eat fast). But by the time I left, the place was packed. So my advice, either show up right as it opens or join the Yelp waitlist because the locals love this place!
LOVE WITCHES BREW EVERY TIME. The food is great the fries are great the coffee is to die for. Never a bad meal.
Love love love LOVEE their food, absolutely delicious, decor is gorgeous and staff is amazing.
Location
-
311 Hempstead Tpke West Hempstead, NY 11552 Hotline: (516) 489-9482
Witches Brew Coffee House is a charming Italian-American café located in West Hempstead, NY. Boasting a unique blend of spooky and cozy ambiance, this café has become a beloved landmark on Long Island. With a vast menu that caters to vegetarians and vegans, Witches Brew offers a delightful array of dishes that are both delicious and memorable.
Customers rave about the incredible food and attentive staff at Witches Brew. The menu includes a variety of options, from well-dressed Caesar salads to delectable desserts like s'mores. The coffee here is a standout, with the Inkwell latte described as buttery and sweet, reminiscent of a Butterbeer.
The atmosphere at Witches Brew is relaxed and comfortable, making it the perfect spot for a date or a study group. The café's gender-neutral restrooms, women-owned status, and commitment to sustainability through plastic-free packaging and reusable tableware further add to its appeal.
While the wait times can be long, loyal customers agree that the wait is worth it. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Witches Brew Coffee House promises a memorable dining experience that combines great food, cozy ambiance, and excellent service.
